Recent Reviews
Search Movie Review Library
About Phil & Carol
Phil & Carol's Rating System


Movie Reviews - Two for the Show

Atonement

Movie Review by Phil & Carol
Phil - Wait for the VideoCarol - Wait for the Video
Perhaps, because we saw this film late, we didn't get the full impact; or perhaps because of all the wonderful reviews, we were destined to be disappointed. And disappointed we were. Set in the early days of World War II, this anti-war film will have timeless appeal while also being sometimes slow and sometimes melodramatic. When a film almost puts me to sleep for the first 15 minutes I have to wonder at it’s worth. And I also wonder how it could be nominated in the “Best Picture of the Year” category. It is a wonderfully acted yet slow moving film. Having not read the novel, there is no way to compare it, but many people with whom I discussed this film said they enjoyed the book much more. So, rent it or read it; your choice!